Login/Create Account
Comparison between company-based Umschulung (betrieblich) and school-based Umschulung (schulisch)
| Factor | Company-based Umschulung (betrieblich) | School-based Umschulung (schulisch) |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | Practical training in a company + theoretical classes in Berufsschule | Fully theoretical training in a training institute or private school |
| Pay (Vergütung) | You receive a monthly salary (Ausbildungsvergütung or a funded contract) | No salary, but you may receive support from Jobcenter or BAföG |
| Practical experience | High – a core part of the program | Low – often limited to short Praktikum periods |
| Program duration | 18 to 36 months depending on the profession | 12 to 30 months depending on the specialization and institute |
| Job opportunities after graduation | Higher – the company may hire you directly | Depends on networks and your own job search efforts |
| Common fields | Handicrafts, industry, technical services, dual professions | Medicine, administration, languages, care, IT, rehabilitation |
| Supervising body | Handwerkskammer / IHK / Berufsschule | Often the institute itself + external exams |
| Ease of admission | Depends on the company – competitive process | Easier admission – apply directly to the institute |
Advantages of company-based Umschulung (betrieblich):
-
Stable income during training (up to 1000–1500 euros)
-
Strong practical experience that improves employment chances
-
Possibility of being hired by the same company later
-
Suitable for those who learn better through practice than theory
Challenges:
-
Requires physical effort and strong communication skills
-
Sometimes hard to combine work and study
Advantages of school-based Umschulung (schulisch):
-
Strong theoretical focus – ideal for those who prefer classic study
-
Suitable for medical, administrative, and educational fields
-
Greater flexibility in study times at some institutes
Challenges:
-
No salary, so external financial support is needed
-
Lack of practical experience may affect immediate employment
Which one suits you best?
| If you... | Best option |
|---|---|
| need income during training | Betrieblich |
| prefer hands-on learning and teamwork | Betrieblich |
| have an academic background or prefer theory-based learning | Schulisch |
| are interested in health, languages, or administration | Schulisch |
| cannot find a training company right now | Schulisch as a start, then look for a Praktikum |
Summary
Company-based Umschulung: closer to the Ausbildung system, offering income and direct practical experience.
School-based Umschulung: suitable for theoretical fields or those unable to work currently, but it requires external funding and higher self-motivation.
ـ* The writers and editors team at the website strives to provide accurate information through intensive research and reviewing multiple sources when writing articles. However, some errors may appear or some information may be unconfirmed. Therefore, please consider the information in the articles as an initial reference and always refer to the competent authorities to obtain confirmed information.
